Skip to the content

Personal Insurance Account Manager

Job Location: Depew, NY, 14043, USA
Job Category: Insurance Sales
Job Type: Full-Time
Remote Type: No

Job Description

**You have unlimited potential. Allow us to give you the chance to shine.**

McMahon Agency, Inc., located in Depew, is a well-established agency and has been in business since 1926. We pride ourselves on taking care of our clients by providing a vast array of insurance products and excellent customer service. We are looking for a dedicated and knowledgeable Personal insurance account manager who is ready to hit the ground running and join our team.

Contact us if you are ready to make a change in your life and are looking to join a company that cares about both our clients and you.

Must currently possess an active Property and Casualty License

OR Willing to assist in licensing a qualified candidate

In office position


  • Base Salary Plus Commission
  • Base Salary Based on Experience
  • Bonus Opportunities
  • Licensing Assistance provided for the qualified individual
  • Full-time
  • Paid Time Off (PTO)
  • Work-Life Balance
  • Evenings Off
  • Weekends Off
  • Holidays Off
  • Paid Holidays
  • 401k Plan
  • Career Growth Opportunities
  • Professional Development
  • Advancement Opportunities
  • Continuing Education Opportunities
  • Ongoing Training Seminars
  • Hands-On Training
  • Professional Work Environment
  • Team Building Activities
  • Retirement Benefits
  • Equipment Provided
  • Paid Sick Leave
  • Family Leave
  • Health Insurance
  • Life Insurance
  • Dental Insurance
  • Disability Insurance
  • Supplemental Insurance


    • Develop insurance quotes, makes sales presentations, and close sales.
    • Maintain client relationships with follow-up phone calls.
    • Foster strong relationships with our customers to maintain a high level of client retention and product loyalty.
    • Assess and identify the wants and needs of your customer(s)
    • Shop renewals


A Property & Casualty license is preferred but will train a qualified individual.
2-3 years of Personal Insurance account manager experience preferred
Agency management System and Microsoft Suite
Possess an upbeat, positive, and enthusiastic attitude.
Professional Office etiquette and Excellent Communication/interpersonal skills
Proficiency to multi-task, follow-thru, and follow up.

View All Job Openings

Apply Now using the form below Or Apply with Indeed

  • Accepted file types: doc, docx, pdf, txt, odt, Max. file size: 59 MB.