Skip to the content
Home > About Us > Insurance Companies

Call Us Today (716) 837-3943

Insurance Companies

As independent agents, we have established long-term, solid relationships with some of the top national and regional carriers in the industry. Our experienced staff will be able to provide comprehensive, expert insurance solutions and service.

For you, our client, this provides competitive pricing, coverage options, and peace of mind that the company providing your insurance coverage meets our standards.

Insurance products are offered through the following insurers: ACentral (Edmeston, NY); Adirondack Insurance Exchange (Buffalo, NY); Allstate Insurance (Roanoke, VA); AmTrust North America (Cleveland, OH); American Collectors Insurance (Cherry Hill, NJ); CNA Surety (Sioux Falls, SD); Chautauqua Patrons (Jamestown, NY); Chubb Group (Warren, NJ); Cincinnati Insurance (Fairfield, OH); Condon Skelly (Moorestown, NJ); Dryden Mutual Insurance Company (Dryden, NY); Erie And Niagara Insurance (Williamsville, NY); Erie Insurance (Erie, PA); Excellus BlueCross BlueShield; Foremost Insurance (Carol Stream, IL); Genesee Patrons Insurance (Batavia, NY); Grundy (Horsham, PA); Guardian Anytime; Hagerty Insurance (Traverse City, MI); The Hanover Insurance Group, Inc. (Worcester, MA); Harleysville Insurance (Harleysville, PA); The Hartford Insurance Group, Inc. (Hartford, CT); Heacock Classic Car Insurance (Cherry Hill, NJ); Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield (Pittsburgh, PA); Independent Health (Buffalo, NY); J.C. Taylor (Upper Darby, PA); K&K Insurance Group (Fort Wayne, IN); Lancer Insurance (Long Beach, NY); Liberty Mutual Insurance (Boston, MA); MVP Health Care (Schenectady, NY); MEMIC (Portland, ME); Merchants Insurance Group (Buffalo, NY); Mercury Insurance (Santa Ana, CA); Michigan Millers Mutual (Lansing, MI); National Benefit Life Ins (Long Island City, NY); NFIP - National Flood Insurance Program (Washington, WA); National Flood Services; National General Insurance Company (Winston-Salem, NC); National Interstate (Richfield, OH); NatGen Premier (Cleveland, OH); New York Central Mutual (Edmeston, NY); NY State Insurance Fund (Albany, NY); Petplan (Newtown Square, PA); Philadelphia Indemnity Insurance Company (Bala Cynwyd, PA); Pie Insurance Services (Washington, DC); Plymouth Rock Assurance (Boston, MA); The Progressive Corporation (Mayfield Village, OH); RT Specialty (Chicago, IL); Safeco Insurance Company of America (Boston, MA); Selective Insurance (Branchville, NJ); ShelterPoint (Great Neck, NY); The Travelers Indemnity Company (Hartford, CT); United Frontier Mutual (Lockport, NY); Union Mutual of Vermont (Montpelier, VT); Univera Healthcare (Buffalo, NY); Unum Group (Chattanooga, TN); Utica National Insurance Group (New Hartford, NY); VFIS (York, PA); The Wright Insurance Group, LLC (St. Petersburg, FL); Zurich American Insurance Company (Schaumburg, IL); and other unaffiliated insurers.

Insurance services are provided by an independent insurance agency. McMahon Agency and its producers are licensed in the states where services are offered. License numbers are available upon request. Availability, eligibility, and coverages may vary by state. Not all products are available in all states.